Your car was totaled: keep it or sell it?
By Cash for Junk Cars Southside Chicago Inc.. Published . Last updated .
After an Illinois insurer totals your car, are you allowed to keep it?
Only in limited cases. Illinois's Department of Insurance says you may keep a totaled car only if the damage is hail that doesn't affect safety, or the car is nine model years old or older. Cash for Junk Cars Southside Chicago Inc. buys kept totaled cars across the South Side and pays at pickup.
A total loss means your insurer decided the car isn’t worth repairing. What happens to the car next depends on Illinois rules and on how old it is.
When Illinois lets you keep a totaled car
The Illinois Department of Insurance explains it directly. To limit chop-shop crime, the Illinois Vehicle Code “does not permit you the right to retain the salvage once the insurance company has deemed your auto a total loss,” with two exceptions:
- The vehicle has only hail damage that doesn’t affect its operational safety.
- The vehicle is nine model years old or older.
If neither applies, the insurer pays the settlement and takes the car. If one does, you may be able to keep it, usually for a smaller payout.
Keep it or let it go
| If you keep it | If the insurer takes it |
|---|---|
| Smaller settlement check | Full settlement under your policy |
| You deal with the damaged car | The insurer handles the car |
| Its title status may change | Nothing left for you to sell |
| You can repair it, or sell it for junk | You shop for a replacement |
For an older car that’s only worth scrap value anyway, keeping it can make sense: you collect the settlement and then sell the car for junk. For a newer car, the decision is usually made for you.
What happens to the title
Insurers can obtain a salvage or junking certificate in their own name after paying the owner or lienholder and giving notice, under 625 ILCS 5/3-117.3. If you keep the car, ask your insurer exactly what paperwork you’ll end up holding. Our guide to salvage and rebuilt titles explains what each document means.
If there’s still a loan
The insurer typically pays the lender listed on the title before you see any money. If the settlement doesn’t cover the balance, you still owe the difference. Our guide to junking a car with a loan covers that gap.
Questions to ask your adjuster
- What will the settlement be if I keep the car, and if I don’t?
- Does my car qualify under the nine-model-year or hail exception?
- What title or certificate will I hold afterward?
- How long do I have to decide?
The Department of Insurance page also covers your rights if you can’t find a comparable replacement after a cash settlement.
Selling a kept total loss
Once you have the car and its paperwork, a junk sale is straightforward. We buy crash-damaged cars from body shops, tow lots and driveways; our page on wrecked and damaged cars covers how. Pickups happen across the South Side, from Avalon Park to Beverly. Get an offer or call (708) 691-3888.
Short answers
- My car is ten years old and was totaled. Can I keep it?
- Under the Illinois Department of Insurance's guidance, a vehicle nine model years old or older is one of the two cases where you may be able to keep it. Your insurer will explain how that changes the settlement.
- If I keep it, can I still sell it to you later?
- Yes. We buy totaled cars that owners kept, usually with the salvage paperwork that follows a total loss.
- Who gets paid first if there's a loan?
- Usually the lender listed on the title. Our guide on junking a car with a loan explains how that works.
The service behind this guide
- Wrecked and damaged cars
Crash, fire and flood damage, tow-yard and body-shop pickups, and what an insurance total means for you.
Related guides
- Salvage and rebuilt titles
What salvage, rebuilt and junk brands mean, and how each affects selling.
- Junking a car with a loan
Liens, payoffs and lien releases, and how to tell if a junk sale still makes sense.
Areas we serve
- Avalon Park
Avalon Park, Marynook and Stony Island Park, straight down 79th Street.
- Beverly
Ridge-top houses, long driveways and the Rock Island stations from 91st to 107th.